A soft 404 means Google fetched a URL, your server replied “all fine” (a 200 status), but the page looked like an error, an empty page or a “not found” message. Google won’t index it. The fix depends on what the page should be: if it’s genuinely gone, make the server return a real 404 or 410; if it should exist, give it real content; and if it redirects to your homepage, point it at a genuine replacement or let it 404. On a small site, first check whether the flagged URLs are pages you actually want found. Many aren’t.
What Google means by “soft 404”
Google’s Page indexing help describes a soft 404 as a page that returns a user-friendly “not found” message without a 404 HTTP response code. It recommends returning a 404 for pages that truly don’t exist, and adding more information to pages that do, so they aren’t mistaken for errors (Search Console Help: Page indexing report, checked 11 November 2026).
Google’s crawler documentation adds the other half: when a page returns a 2xx status but the content suggests an error, an empty page or an error message, Search Console shows a soft 404 (Google: How HTTP status codes affect Google’s crawlers, last updated 4 February 2026, checked 11 November 2026).
In plain terms: the server and the page are telling Google two different stories, and Google believes the page.
Do you need to worry?
Sometimes. Ask one question about each flagged URL: do I want this page to appear in Google?
- Yes (a service page, a product, a guide, your contact page): it’s worth fixing, because right now it isn’t indexed.
- No (an old promotion, a deleted page, an empty archive): it’s low priority. Tidying the status code is good housekeeping, but it won’t change much.
A soft 404 isn’t a penalty on the rest of your site. And Google itself says that if your site has fewer than 500 pages, you probably don’t need the Page indexing report at all; quick site: searches for your key pages will tell you whether they’re indexed. Use the report when something important seems to be missing.
The usual causes on small business sites
| What’s happening | Why Google calls it a soft 404 | Usual fix |
|---|---|---|
| A deleted page redirects to your homepage | The homepage isn’t a replacement for what was asked for. Google’s 404 help names redirecting to the homepage instead of returning a 404 as a soft 404 | Redirect to a genuinely equivalent page, or let the old URL return 404 or 410 |
| Your “page not found” template returns 200 | It says “not found” but the server says “OK” | Ask your developer or platform to make missing pages return a real 404 status |
| An empty listing page: a category, tag, search or filter page showing “No posts found” | Nothing on the page but a message | Remove links to it, add content, or let it 404 or carry noindex if it’s meant to stay empty |
| A service or product page that now just says “no longer available” or “coming soon” | Little content beyond an error-like message | If it’s gone for good, return 404 or 410, or redirect to a true replacement. If it’s coming back, keep useful details on the page |
| A very thin page: a heading and a form, nothing else | Looks empty to Google | Add the information a customer needs: what it is, who it’s for, price range, how to start |
| A JavaScript-built page that shows its error only in the browser | The server sends 200 before the script decides the page doesn’t exist | Follow Google’s JavaScript SEO guidance: redirect to a URL that returns 404, or add noindex to error views |
| The page didn’t load properly for Google (a failed script, a blocked resource, a timeout) | Google saw a broken or blank render | Check what Google actually saw (below) and fix the loading problem |
How to check a flagged URL in five minutes
- In Search Console, open Indexing > Pages and click Soft 404 in the “Why pages aren’t indexed” table.
- Click an example URL, then the inspect icon to open URL Inspection.
- Click Test live URL, then View tested page to see a screenshot of how Google renders it. Google suggests this step in its help page.
- Ask: does the screenshot look like a real, useful page? Or blank, broken or “not found”?
- Check the status code your server sends. In Chrome, open the page, right-click, choose Inspect, open the Network tab and reload. The first row (the page itself) shows the status: 200, 301, 404 and so on.
Now you know which story the server is telling, and which the page is telling.
How to fix it, by situation
The page is gone and has no replacement. Make the URL return 404 or 410. Google treats them the same way, and says returning a 404 for a deleted page with no replacement is the right thing to do. Remove it from your sitemap and your own menus and links.
The page moved. Use a permanent (301 or 308) redirect to the new address, page to page. Not to the homepage.
The page should exist but is thin. Write it properly. A service page needs enough for someone to decide whether to contact you: what you do, for whom, roughly what it costs, how long it takes, and how to get started.
It’s an empty listing page. If it will fill up soon, leave it and don’t link to it until it does. If it will stay empty, stop linking to it and let it 404, or add noindex.
It’s a temporary gap (a seasonal service, a fully booked course). Keep the page live with real content: what the service is, when it returns, what to do meanwhile. That reads as a real page, not an error.
It’s a JavaScript problem. Hand Google’s JavaScript guidance to whoever built the site; it describes two approaches in a few lines.
If the same URL also shows up as a duplicate, our guide to canonical tags explains how Google chooses between near-identical pages.
After you’ve fixed it
Back in the Soft 404 details page, click Validate fix once every instance is sorted. Google says validation typically takes up to about two weeks, and sometimes much longer. If one URL still fails, validation stops and you can see which one. You can also skip validation: Google updates the count whenever it recrawls the pages anyway.
A hypothetical example
Invented for illustration, not a client case. A home cleaning company sees six soft 404s:
- Four are old festive promotion pages that redirect to the homepage. Nobody needs them. The company removes the redirects so they return 404, and takes them out of the sitemap.
- One is its “Carpet cleaning” page, which says only “Coming soon” with a contact form. The service has actually been running for months. The owner adds what’s included, a price range, how long it takes and what to prepare, then clicks Validate fix.
- One is an empty blog tag page linked from the footer. The link is removed.
Total time: about an hour. The only fix that mattered for customers was the carpet cleaning page; the rest was tidying.
What’s in your control, and what isn’t
In your control: the status codes your site returns, where your redirects point, how much useful content each page has, and which pages you link to and list in your sitemap.
Not in your control: how quickly Google recrawls and updates the report, whether it indexes a page once fixed (indexing is never guaranteed), and how it ranks the page afterwards. Fixing a soft 404 makes a page eligible again. It doesn’t promise traffic.